Walk into The Privateer, and you'll immediately notice the heat emanating from our coal fire oven. This isn't just any pizza oven—it's a direct connection to the legendary coal-fired pizzerias of the American Northeast.
The History of Coal Fire Pizza
Coal-fired pizza has its roots in New Haven, Connecticut, where Italian immigrants in the early 1900s adapted their traditional wood-fired techniques to use anthracite coal, which was abundant in the region.
The result was a pizza unlike any other: intensely charred, with a thin, blistered crust and a distinctive smoky flavor that has made coal-fired pizza legendary.
Why 900+ Degrees?
Our oven maintains temperatures exceeding 900 degrees Fahrenheit. At this extreme heat:
- Pizzas cook in just 2-3 minutes
- The crust develops beautiful leopard spots of char
- Toppings caramelize perfectly without overcooking
- The dough puffs up at the edges while staying thin in the center
The intense heat of a coal fire oven creates a crust that's simultaneously crispy and chewy—a texture impossible to achieve at lower temperatures.
The Art of Fire Management
Maintaining the perfect coal fire is an art that our pizzaiolos have mastered through years of practice. The coal must be carefully managed throughout the day to maintain consistent temperatures and even heat distribution.
Come see our skilled team in action and taste the difference that real coal fire makes.



