In June 2022, Wine Spectator handed out its annual Awards of Excellence. Twenty-six San Diego County restaurants made the list. Only one was a casual pizza place.

The Award

Wine Spectator's Award of Excellence recognizes restaurants with wine lists that go beyond the basics — programs that show real thought about selection, value, and variety. Fine dining spots fill the list every year. A coal-fired pizza restaurant in Oceanside isn't the usual contender.

That's partly the point.

The Program

Susan Porter-Guarino, our wine and beverage director and certified sommelier, built the list with a specific philosophy: organize by type and boldness, not by how much you want to spend. Whites, rosés, reds — each grouped by weight, lightest to fullest. The idea is you find what you like, not what someone else decided you should drink at a given price point.

California dominates the sales — about 60%, mostly from the central coast. Paso Robles, Santa Barbara. Regions turning out serious bottles without Napa's markup. Fallbrook Winery produces our private label. Beach House Winery from Ramona rotates through.

But the list stretches further than most people expect. Porter-Guarino has been pushing into regions that don't show up on typical American wine lists — Georgia, Turkey, Armenia, Tasmania.

"Six years ago, I couldn't sell anyone on wine from Tasmania," she told San Diego Magazine. Now those bottles move.

The Approach

What makes the program work isn't the number of bottles. It's the attitude. Porter-Guarino started her own wine journey with Sutter Home white zinfandel — she's said as much publicly. No pretense about where people start. The list is built to meet you where you are and point you somewhere interesting.

A coal-fired pizza place with a Wine Spectator award. It sounds like a mismatch until you taste the wine alongside the pizza. Then it just sounds right.

Originally published by San Diego Magazine. Read the full article →