Wine Spectator published a national list of pizza restaurants with terrific wine lists. Ten spots across the country. The Privateer was one of them.
The Recognition
This wasn't a local roundup or a regional best-of. Wine Spectator looked at pizza restaurants nationwide — places where the wine program matches the quality of what's coming out of the oven — and picked ten. Being the Oceanside entry on that list puts the wine program in a different conversation.
The magazine highlighted Susan Porter-Guarino's curation: 148 wines by the bottle, 40 by the glass. California anchors the list — Lodi Zinfandel, Paso Robles Cabernet — with Italian selections and a private-label wine produced locally. Flight options with detailed tasting descriptions let people explore without committing to a full bottle.
The Pies They Featured
Wine Spectator called out several pizzas alongside the wine program. The Chemistry Pie — tomato sauce, mozzarella, pepperoni, house-made sausage. The Surf Ride Pie with Grana Padano, pepperoni, and bacon. The Raen Pie running white sauce, provolone, fior di latte, and prosciutto di Parma. The classic cheese.
The pies are the reason the wine program exists in the first place. Coal-fired pizza has enough char, fat, and flavor intensity to stand up to serious wine. The two push each other.
What It Means
A lot of pizza places treat their wine list as an afterthought — a few safe reds, maybe a Pinot Grigio. And a lot of wine-focused restaurants wouldn't touch a coal oven. The Privateer has always done both, not as a gimmick but because that's what Charlie and Jamey set out to build: a neighborhood place where the pizza and the wine are both worth your attention.
Wine Spectator noticed. Ten restaurants, nationwide. We're one of them.
Originally published by Wine Spectator. Read the full article →



